metal talk
Search here...
metal talk


  JONATHAN CHURCHILL: DEFENDING OUR ISLAND

LOU REED & METALLICA
'Lulu'
(Warner Bros)
Released: 31st October 2011


jonathan churchill



You know the dread that comes over you when a friend offers to show you all their wedding photos? And the video too? Well that's the feeling you ought to get if somebody offers to play you a track from Lou Reed and Metallica's collaboration, 'Lulu'. I've had the opportunity to listen to the entire album. All of it. Every note. It's fair to say that it has left a lasting impression.

metallicaloureedlulu

MetalTalk.net is all about positivity. We love our Metal and we're certainly not here to knock rock stars with fragile egos and too much money off their perches. Something, however, has gone horribly wrong and it's only fair that we should hold a Metal inquisition.

The first thing to establish is exactly what on earth this is. Well, according to the official press release, 'Lulu' is a set of extended songs inspired by German expressionist Frank Wedekind's early 20th Century plays, 'Earth Spirit' and 'Pandora's Box' (much admired by Freud). The plays, originally published in 1904 and set in Germany, Paris and London in the 1890s, whirl between the points of view of Lulu, an inverted-Eve-like cipher-mirror of desire and abuse, and the people who fall desperately in love with her. Then she meets Jack The Ripper...

Article continues below...



Reed had previously sketched out some lyrics and after meeting with Metallica in 2009, they decided to work together. At first glance, a genuinely innovative and exciting idea. The power and intensity of Metallica in full flow, but with a lyricist and poet who can write words that infiltrate your soul.

As a fully inducted member of the Rock 'n' Roll Hall of Fame, Lou Reed has earned a great deal of respect throughout his career. His dark, obscure and nihilistic outpourings are perfect for heavy Metal and there's a genuine resonance between the music and lyrics on Lulu. It's unfortunate then that, as far as I can tell, it's pure self-indulgent nonsense.

What we have here is a mixed bag of pretentious lyrics and tedious music which surprises and delights in equal measure. Surprises because it's much more boring and faux-intellectual than I could have imagined. And delights because it is hilarious to think that thousands of unsuspecting rednecks in the Deep South may be getting this for Christmas alongside their new baseball cap and Kid Rock's Greatest Hits.

In my opinion, Metallica have struggled for years now to lay the ghost of 'The Black Album' to rest. Regardless of your opinion on thatrecord, it is a monster and it's not that they aren't talented enough to move forward, but I've always felt they lost their sense of purpose. As a fervently anti-establishment band in the early eighties, 'The Black Album' introduced them to the mainstream. It simultaneously launched them into the stratosphere and ruined their Metal credentials. Millions of people who would never touch a Slayer or Megadeth album suddenly embraced Metallica, who just recently performed at a corporate event for Salesforce.com. That's the sort of behaviour you expect from KISS, not a proper thrash Metal band.

Lou Reed, on the other hand, clearly needs an outlet for his poetry. The bin would be my suggestion. However, Metallica have decided to put it to music. Fair enough. They probably weren't sure how to politely say "no", and the next thing you know they're all in a recording studio, and one thing led to another. I'm presuming Trent Reznor had a similar issues when Rob Halford popped in one day wearing a feather boa and eyeliner, clutching some surreal lyrics, asking to make an industrial album with his new band, 2wo.

What interests me is that the album is very true to itself and is totally non-commercial. It means that if this sells or is critically acclaimed, it will be on the strength of the material and not because there are two famous names involved. The cover artwork is provocative and blatantly sets the tone for what's inside. And the overall lyrical content and musical feel is basically the mad Danish director, Lars von Trier, set to music. So far so Lou Reed then.

Getting under the skin of 'Lulu' requires patience, stamina and a very open mind. It's a record that will polarise opinion for years to come, but I'm sure - just like Meatloaf's 'Bat Out Of Hell III' - there is somebody, somewhere, alone and in a black T-shirt, who will genuinely appreciate this record.

Notable moments include:

'The View', an interesting slow-paced track with a gentle drum intro and an introspective poetry-style spoken word delivery. There's a real sense of Michael Stipe's vocal from REM's 'New Adventures In Hi-Fi', another deliberately non-commercial piece. This track reminds me strongly of 'E-bow The Letter'. It's just nowhere near as good.

'Frustration' focuses just on the drums and vocals for large parts. It's interesting to hear Lars freestyling with Reed droning over the top. It's certainly different and definitely doesn't sound like it was written by an eight year-old with ADHD.

According to press interviews with the band, 'Junior Dad', the nineteen-minute finale, brought James and Kirk to tears. The last eight minutes or so is just the sound of what may be a viola gently playing one note. It will reduce most Metallica fans to tears.

anthraxworshipmusic

Conclusion:

Reviewing a collaboration is a tricky business. Is this a Metallica album featuring Lou Reed or a Lou Reed album featuring Metallica? The difference is important. Lou Reed being a seminal sixties and seventies artistic pioneer. Metallica being the world's most popular heavy Metal band. They have widely different audiences and little crossover.

A new Lou Reed album is to be treated with extreme caution. It's bound to be 'artistic' and 'challenging' and have an alleged intellectual depth. Invariably, it won't be popular.

These days though, a new Metallica album is, in fact, also to be treated with caution! Recent releases have been - um - 'artistic', 'challenging' and have had an alleged new-found intellectual depth. Invariably, they aren't popular.

Having put 'Lulu' through a Metal Inquisition and tightened the thumbscrews on this bizarre experiment, it's fair to say that I think this is very much a Lou Reed record. Metallica have done a fair job of creating an audio landscape for his poetic gushing, but the lyrics and delivery by Reed is so dominant that it's easy to overlook Metallica's contribution. As such, if you're a fan of Lou Reed, this is another great challenging artistic piece with hidden depths. I'm sure it will win a Grammy or find favour with pseudo-intellectuals who enjoy alternative sounds.

If you're Metallica fan, I'd suggest you don't put yourself through the torment of this record. There's little here for thrash fans and it's best viewed as an experiment and not a proper Metallica record. For those brave enough to take the 'Lulu' challenge - please post your comments below or on the MetalTalk.net Facebook page! For me - it's a thumbs down. It's not an album I'd ever listen to under any circumstances, but credit to Metallica for trying something new. However, Anthrax and Megadeth have both been busy in the studio proving that their 1980s success was no fluke. Megadeth's previous two albums have been outstanding and Anthrax's 'Worship Music' is easily one of the albums of the year. The question must be asked why on earth Metallica aren't able to find a similar vein of form? They certainly seem to have time on their hands to showcase their talents with Lou Reed.

Listen to whole album:

http://www.loureedmetallica.com/listen-to-lulu.php


26.10.11

Jonathan Churchill. MetalTalk.net
Follow me on Twitter: MetalTalk_1976


Share |






 

scorpions EXCLUSIVE: SCORPIONS TO RELEASE NEW ALBUM IN EARLY 2018 AND CONTINUE TOURING
Brand new opus will be their first with Mikkey, who was Motörhead drummer for twenty-three years...

nidingr EXCLUSIVE UK PREMIERE: NIDINGR RELEASE FIRST SINGLE FROM FORTHCOMING NEW ALBUM
"To me this song solidifies a thing that is fucking great about Nidingr - no rules..."

iron maiden BREAKING NEWS: CELLAR DARLING SIGN WITH NUCLEAR BLAST
"We are proud and excited to have found partners who understand our music and share our vision..."

iron maiden BREAKING NEWS: IRON MAIDEN TO TOUR NORTH AMERICA IN JUNE/JULY
Support on all North American dates will be Ghost and tickets go on-sale from next Friday...

iron maiden HOME OF METAL TO JOIN BLACK SABBATH ON THEIR FINAL DATES
"Fans are our lifeblood, they've always been there to support us. The audiences have been getting bigger as the tour progressed..."

hammerfall EXCLUSIVE WORLD PREMIERE: HAMMERFALL UNLEASH NEW VIDEO FOR 'BUILT TO LAST' TITLE TRACK
Hammerfall are currently on tour throughout Europe and there are plenty of dates left to catch their new epic show...

grim reaper GRIM REAPER'S STEVE GRIMMETT SEVERELY ILL IN ECUADOR
"Unfortunately the operation didn't work and Steve is currently in the operating theatre having limbs removed..."

bill price GUNS N' ROSES AND SEX PISTOLS PRODUCER/ENGINEER BILL PRICE HAS SADLY PASSED AWAY
Price worked with Rod Stewart, INXS, Pete Townshend, Elton John, The Jesus And Mary Chain and Big Audio Dynamite...

fish marillion FISH CELEBRATES 30th ANNIVERSARY OF 'CLUTCHING AT STRAWS' WITH UK TOUR
"These are the only dates this year as because of my shoulder operation next month with the extensive recovery period..."

ross the boss UK EXCLUSIVE: ROSS THE BOSS ANNOUNCES TOUR DATES AHEAD OF SPECIAL GUEST SLOT ON MetalTalk RADIO THIS WEEK
"We are going to devastate every audience, every night, without mercy..."

dokken WAS BREAKING NEWS: CLASSIC DOKKEN LINE-UP CONFIRMED FOR RAMBLIN' MAN
Dokken, Lynch, Pilson and Brown will play together in England for the first time in around a quarter-of-a-century...

grand magus DEF LEPPARD AND POISON ANNOUNCE NORTH AMERICAN DATES
"I could not be more excited. I know all of us will give one thousand percent on stage..."

grand magus VIKINGS TO INVADE YORKSHIRE: GRAND MAGUS TO HEADLINE KEIGHLEY FESTIVAL
"Get your tickets now and prepare to raise your fists and bang your heads for the glory of Metal!"

armored saint ARMORED SAINT UK TOUR DATES AND 'MARCH OF THE SAINT (LIVE)' VIDEO ARE HERE
"We're really looking forward to playing these select UK shows in March..."

screaming eagles SCREAMING EAGLES TO FEATURE IN NEW AMAZON PRIME SERIES STARRING BRYAN CRANSTON
The band will be releasing a live mini-album in spring 2017 and will be touring in the UK, France and Germany throughout the year...

martyrd MARTYRD SET TO OPEN FOR METAL ALLEGIANCE, MARTY FRIEDMAN AND GUS G
"NAMM is a blast, total musical sensory overload from every direction. It’s like getting lost in a hurricane - I can't wait."

john garcia EXCLUSIVE WORLD PREMIERE: JOHN GARCIA UNLEASHES 'GIVE ME 250ml'
"This record is one of the most important of my career, difficult and challenging to do, but worth every minute of sweat!"

avenged sevenfold WAS BREAKING NEWS: AVENGED SEVENFOLD TO OPEN LONDON POP-UP STORE
The shop will be hosting in-store raffles and giveaways of exclusive and signed merchandise...

avenged sevenfold ROCK MEETS CLASSIC 2017 EUROPE LINE-UP IS HERE
Rock meets Classic has a terrific vibe and the legendary cross-over-project combines emotional classic with world-famous rock songs...

paddy goes to holyhead PADDY GOES TO HOLYHEAD ARE BACK FOR THE CRAIC ON ST PATRICK'S NIGHT
The band supposedly played their last ever gig two years ago in celebration of their 30th anniversary...

nightlord EXCLUSIVE THE UNKNOWN BAND WHO INFLUENCED METALLICA AIRS ON MetalTalk RADIO
Also featuring is the very first UK radio airplay of Cellar Darling, the band created by former Eluveitie members...

epica EPICA RELEASE 'BEYOND THE MATRIX' VIDEO - WATCH IT HERE
"The energy that lives within 'Beyond The Matrix' is extremely contagious. It will sweep you off your feet when the melodies enter your mind..."

nightlord JOHN COGHLAN'S QUO BACK ON THE ROAD AGAIN
John Coghlan's Quo have announced UK dates across the Kingdom that will see them busy throughout the year...

jimmy bain JIMMY BAIN'S WIDOW NEEDS OUR HELP
"Jimmy recently passed away without a proper will in place and now his better half is in trouble..."

michael schenker MICHAEL SCHENKER FEST 'LIVE' TOKYO FEATURING BARDEN, BONNET AND McAULEY OUT IN MARCH
Features guest appearances from some of the greatest rock vocalists who have worked with Schenker...

ozzy osbourne OZZY OSBOURNE OVERDOSED WHEN SHARON HAD CANCER
"I watched him scoop his hands into a bowl of pills, swallow a handful of something, and then wash it down with vodka..."

eluveitie ELUVEITIE NEW LINE-UP IS COMPLETE, FIRST GIGS GO DOWN A STORM
"Above all we're super happy and thankful that we're complete again and given the chance to have such gifted musicians on board..."

gene simmons GENE SIMMONS RESTAURANT HONOURS US VETS
"The opening day of every Rock & Brews is dedicated to our vets, the public is not allowed in."

deep purple DEEP PURPLE SUE THEIR LONG-TIME ACCOUNTANT FOR FOUR MILLION
"I'm completely irresponsible. I'm ignorant about money as a commodity — I have never really understood it."

tony iommi UK EXCLUSIVE: VINCE NEIL FIST FIGHT WITH BOY GEORGE STOPPED AS ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER SHUTS UP PRESIDENT TRUMP
"They screwed up. That was a huge miss and someone should have a talking-to."

tony iommi GLENN HUGHES: "I'M THRILLED TO BE TOURING THE UK IN JANUARY"
"Let's get 2017 going with a killer night for ROCK lovers, movers and shakers. I'm in. Let's go!"

tony iommi TONY IOMMI HAS SUCCESSFUL THROAT OPERATION AND IS CANCER-FREE
"We had to have it checked in case it may have been cancerous. But it turns out it wasn't, which I found out Christmas Day..."

ronnie montrose RONNIE MONTROSE REMEMBERED: ALL-STAR MEMORIAL CONCERT TO TAKE PLACE AT NAMM 2017
"Ronnie helped light a fire in me and made me want to approach guitar playing with that kind of zeal and expression..."

motorhead beer PHIL CAMPBELL AND MIKKEY DEE TO APPEAR AT MOTÖRHEAD BEER LAUNCH IN LONDON
This is sure to be one superb night with beer, live music and Motörhead, but not necessarily in that order...

tony iommi BLACK STAR RIDERS PREMIERE 'TESTIFY OR SAY GOODBYE'
Black Star Riders are set to release their forthcoming album 'Heavy Fire' on 3rd February via Nuclear Blast...

tony iommi BREAKING NEWS: TONY IOMMI DROPS HEAVY METAL AND JOINS THE CHOIR
"It's a bit different to Sabbath!" says Tony, in probably the biggest understatement of all time...

tony iommi ROCK MUSIC IN SUPERHERO MOVIES
It's pretty wild to think that this whole ride that is the Marvel Cinematic Universe started off with a little AC/DC...

jimi hendrix JIMI HENDRIX'S WAH-WAH PEDAL AND AMP SURVIVES AUCTION HOUSE BURGLARY
"It was a very positive and uplifting experience to work for Jimi. He was like a shaman, a medicine man, a preacher.."

alestorm ALESTORM ENTER FLORIDA STUDIO BUT A CHALLENGE AWAITS THEM BACK IN BLIGHTY
"It is full of epic songs about pirates, drinking, and pseudoscientific cryptogeography..."

queen QUEEN GUITARIST BRIAN MAY WANTS TO BRING ROCK TO A NEW GENERATION
"It was actually all very planned and deliberate and came totally out of Freddie's fevered imagination..."

phil lynott MASS TRIBUTES PAID TO PHIL LYNOTT ON ANNIVERSARY OF HIS PASSING
"God bless my old friend, thanks for the faith you showed in allowing me to record your music..."

black country communion BLACK COUNTRY COMMUNION ENTER STUDIO TO BEGIN WORK ON FOURTH ALBUM
"One thing I want to make clear to everybody across air nation is that Joe Bonamassa and I never fell out..."

hair metal heaven BLAZE BAYLEY BRAND NEW ALBUM AND WORLD TOUR DETAILS ARE HERE
'Endure And Survive' is set for release on 3rd March 2017 and will be accompanied by a world tour totalling some 120 shows...

hair metal heaven HAIR METAL HEAVEN FESTIVAL ANNOUNCES FIRST ACTS FOR INAUGURAL EVENT
The Hair Metal Heaven Festival has a very eighties feel to it, as the team behind it explain here...

motorhead EXCLUSIVE TEST PILOT DROPS TWO GRAND ON NEW MOTÖRHEAD VIDEO SLOT
"A few spins later and I turned up a row of gold Snaggletooths which promptly caught fire and the voice of the man himself commanded: 'Turn it up!'"

deep purple DEEP PURPLE RELEASE NEW 'inFinite' TRAILERS AND EXPECTED ALBUM FORMATS
'Time For Bedlam', the first single which was revealed late last year, is available as instant grat as part of the digital album pre-order...

hollywood AEROSMITH FAREWELL TOUR COULD LAST FIVE YEARS
"We had a talk a few weeks back about going into the studio. When that'll happen, though, I'm not sure. We certainly have plenty of ideas..."

rick parfitt EXCLUSIVE MEGADETH MAINMAN DAVE MUSTAINE REVEALS HE'S AN ARSENAL FC SUPPORTER
Megadeth, formed in Los Angeles in 1983 after Dave left Metallica, are currently enjoying a rich vein of form...

hollywood FORMER PEARL JAM DRUMMER HITS OUT AT THE BAND
"We need music, each other and the spirit of Rock & Roll now, more than ever before..."

hollywood HOLLYWOOD SIGN CHANGED BY PRANKSTERS TO READ 'HOLLYWEED'
"An artist's role throughout history has been to create representations of the culture he exists in..."

metallica METALLICA GUITARIST KIRK HAMMETT'S HOME FOR SALE FOR £16m
Apparently a house like this doubles its asking price every six or seven years...

kiss EXCLUSIVE KISS' GENE SIMMONS DROPS BIGGEST HINT YET THAT ACE FREHLEY REUNION IS ON
Over 7,000 likes later, fans are in big speculation that it really is going to happen...

rick parfitt WAS BREAKING NEWS: BLOODSTOCK UNVEIL SECOND 2017 HEADLINER
"Megadeth had a blast last time and I can't wait to bring the Dystopia World Tour to Bloodstock this Summer."

rick parfitt EXCLUSIVE JOHN COGHLAN REVEALS TWO NEW TRACKS WITH RICK PARFITT ARE NEARLY READY FOR RELEASE
"It was going to be Status Quo PLC [Parfitt, Lancaster, Coghlan] and that was Francis' idea originally."

wizz wizzard WIZZ WIZZARD VOCALIST WIZZ BEAUPREZ HAS PASSED AWAY
Wizz Wizzard were signed to Rock Sector Records and labelmate Chris Appleton of Absolva led the tributes...

ronnie james dio RONNIE JAMES DIO TO TOUR IN 2017
"It was very emotional. I didn't think that I was gonna cry, but I did. I broke down...."

metal talk
© All written site content is copyright MetalTalk.net 2008-2017, unless otherwise stated, and is not to be used without prior permission.
Ads raid data recovery