metal talk
facebook
Type band name, album name, artists name etc here...
Search all our articles by typing band name, album name, artists name etc here...
news now
metal talk






  MICHAEL DOWNIE TAKES A LOOK INTO DAB (DIGITAL AUDIO BROADCASTING) RADIO

Michael Downie

michael downie

Pin It
Share |


dab radio

For best part of a decade and a half, DAB (Digital Audio Broadcasting) has been in place here in the UK. From its inception it promised so much. More stations, more content, higher quality and overall, it was supposed to make the old analogue FM and AM services redundant.

With the prevalence of subscription TV and digital freeview, the analogue TV signal has now been shut down across the UK with only a couple of years lead time. So why, 15 years on from the consumer rollout of DAB has it not become the standard?

Radio is still a massive part of the day to day lives of people in this country. According to the latest RAJAR data, Chris Evans at BBC Radio 2 is posting listener figures above 10 million every day and Nick Grimshaw on the opposing breakfast show on Radio 1 is getting 6.3 million listeners a day. So across two national shows you have nearly a quarter of the adult population of the UK. However, these are FM channels, so what about DAB stations?

Article continues below...

   


Well, they are significantly lower. The RAJAR data for DAB stations isn't as easily available as it is for BBC FM stations (they aren't reported in the news and you need to be a paid subscriber to RAJAR to get the data), however, the audience share percentages are available. Planet Rock maintains a share of 0.5% of the radio audience; Absolute 80s holds just 0.2%. For comparison, BBC Radio 1, across all its shows averages out at 7.9% of the radio audience. So the question here is; why aren't more people listening to DAB stations?

Most of the reasons for this can be attributed to technology. Technologically speaking, there are two reasons for this:

Firstly, the availability of the hardware to listen to digital radio. While it's very easy and actually quite cheap to buy a DAB radio, the hardware hasn't really found its way into the place that most people listen to the radio; the car.

That's right, studies have indicated that a large proportion of listeners do so while driving a car. Now, this presents an issue for DAB stations. In the UK, digital radio receivers have been available for cars for a while, but usually only as an option extra for an extra expense. Until you reach the higher prestige cars (BMW, Audi, Mercedes etc), digital receivers are not standard items. Most cars nowadays come with CD players/changers or iPhone/Mp3 connections but they also tend to be lumped with a normal FM and AM receiver. Considering the cost of the options to upgrade to a DAB radio, most consumers don't really see the need for it and simply don't bother.

The second issue with technology is the actual audio itself. DAB has a limited bandwidth. This isn't defined per channel, but there is simply a finite amount of information that can be passed over the spectrum in general. All of the organisations providing digital radio stations have to play nicely with each other so they can all get a reasonable quality stream to the listeners.

This presents several issues for the smaller independent broadcasters. In most cases, smaller broadcasters have to continually drop the quality of their audio streams or lose out completely to the bigger competition. Planet Rock radio, for example, recently dropped their audio stream down to 80kbps mono. Yes, MONO. BBC Radio 4's digital offering drops from 128kbps stereo to 80kbps mono after 6pm every day. For a talk station, like R4 or TalkSport (which broadcasts 64kbps mono), you're listening to people talking so the lower bitrates aren't a huge issue, but for music stations, especially the likes of Planet Rock, it's almost a killer blow.

dab radio

Doing an unscientific test, I loaded up Planet Rock in a friend's car and compared it to Kerrang! radio and two FM radio stations, BBC Radio 1 and Capital FM. What I noticed was an immediate difference between the FM and DAB stations, in terms of volume and clarity. This, I wasn't surprised at. FM stations use huge amounts of post compression to maintain a dynamically level sound which naturally can push the volume up, or at the very least make it appear to be louder.

It was when I compared the two DAB stations that I got the largest shock. I've long held the belief that Kerrang! radio was the poorer quality of the two main digital rock stations. I have heard both stations through my Sky TV service and I've always gravitated to Planet Rock as a higher quality output, both in content and sound quality. Yet today, when I compared the two, Planet Rock sounded thin, cold and slightly crackly. Kerrang! wasn't amazing but it was a definite improvement from PR. I even went to the effort to adjust the EQ settings on the car stereo to see if I could coax a better sound from PR but alas, nothing was forthcoming.

Commercially, DAB appears to have been a failure. The digital only stations are constantly being sold and rebought by different companies who are then intent on making them profitable, resulting in severe cuts which can only then hamper the quality of the output. Less content, more adverts and more dissatisfied listeners tuning out.

Is there any way to improve DAB?

There is, but the UK is one of the handful of countries around the world which have not taken on the newest technology. DAB uses MP2 encoding to maintain a smaller bandwidth cost for each stream. It's universally agreed that it is not as good as the widely accepted MP3 format, but it is what it is. DAB+ is a newer version which has been adopted around the globe and boasts a significant increase in quality. It uses the newer, more efficient AAC+ format which maintains a small bandwidth footprint similar to MP2 but it encodes the data in a more competent way, allowing for an increase in quality without an increase in the size of the footprint.

However, DAB+ isn't likely to be taken on in the UK any time soon. Existing DAB hardware isn't forward compatible, so they will not be able to play content broadcast in DAB+. Considering the government and public broadcasting bodies have spent the last decade trying to convince people to invest in DAB, it would be a PR nightmare to then convince everyone to upgrade their hardware again lest it become obsolete. So we are pretty much stuck with a poor service simply because the powers that be didn't jump on the DAB+ bandwagon soon enough.

dab radio

So what does that mean for the likes of Planet Rock? I honestly don't know. The lowest bitrate that they can drop to in order to save costs and bandwidth would be 64kbps mono, however, this is nigh on unlistenable for most people and borders on an actual crime for the rest of us.

The failings of DAB was based around the need for quantity of content over quality. The amount of the radio spectrum that OFCOM allowed for the service was far too narrow for the amount of stations that were proposed. Currently, internet only services are beginning to take off in a more significant way. The likes of Bloodstock Radio is gaining listeners daily, Q Radio has thrived ever since it became a satellite/internet only station and many more independent stations are popping up every day.

Internet radio is easier and easier to find. With the prevalence of smart phones and unlimited data plans, it is very easy for a listener to use a mobile app and stream the radio across the 3G or 4G networks.

DAB was a good idea, but it was so poorly managed that it never managed to catch up to the technology that was developed in its wake.

What are your thoughts and do you use DAB Radio?


8.5.13




Pin It
Share |






 
nicko mcbrain AN AUDIENCE WITH NICKO McBRAIN ANNOUNCED FOR THIS SUNDAY IN LONDON
Nicko will not be doing any drumming at the event but it will a chance for fans to meet the legend up close and personal...

lemmy MOTORHEAD 40th ANNIVERSARY TOUR ALL GOING WRONG AS ANOTHER GIG IS PULLED AFTER THREE SONGS
Lemmy let out a sigh and announced: "I can't do it", before leaving the stage with the rest of the band...

edagr winter EDGAR WINTER ANNOUNCES EUROPEAN TOUR
"Are Y'all ready for The Monster?" Edgar Winter hits European shores including a UK date in December...

ghost GHOST ANNOUNCE UK LEG OF EUROPEAN HEADLINE TOUR
Prepare for the full Ghost experience with tickets available from 4th September...

iron maiden IRON MAIDEN RELEASE VIDEO GAME BASED ON 'SPEED OF LIGHT'
This is your chance to control Eddie Donkey Kong style...

lemmy MOTORHEAD PULL SALT LAKE CITY CONCERT AFTER FOUR SONGS
A statement on the official Motorhead Facebook page said: "The people are great, but the air is just too thin..."

heavy metal kids HEAVY METAL KIDS ANNOUNCE GARY HOLTON TRIBUTE GIG
The show marks the 30th anniversary of Gary's death. He passed away at the age of 33 due to his excessive rock 'n roll lifestyle...

the sword THE SWORD TO COMMENCE UK TOUR IN SEPTEMBER
The tour is in support of their fifth album 'High Country'...

wolf GENTLEMANS PISTOLS ANNOUNCE LONDON SHOW AT THE UNDERWORLD
"We hope you can dust off the Monday blues and join us for a debauched evening of wine, whiskey and song..."

wolf WOLF ANNOUNCE TOUR WITH ENFORCER
"This package is so much Metal that everyone coming to the shows will have a hard time passing airport security and metal detectors for a foreseeable future..."

jared james nichols JARED JAMES NICHOLS TO RELEASE 'HIGHWAYMAN' EP
The EP features the new single 'We're An American Band'...

michael monroe MICHAEL MONROE REVEALS 'BLACKOUT STATES' ARTWORK + CO-HEADLINE TOUR WITH HARDCORE SUPERSTAR
"It has all the ingredients of a perfect rock n' roll record - strong melodic songs with great meaningful lyrics that defy all clichés..."

turbowolf TURBOWOLF ANNOUNCE UK, EUROPE & US TOUR DATES
"Seeing all your wonderful faces, staring into those expectant eyes, and giving you all exactly what you're looking for, and maybe a little bit more..."

mike shinoda MIKE SHINODA'S FORT MINOR TO PLAY FIRST LONDON SHOW IN 10 YEARS
Shinoda will fit in these special one man shows around Linkin Park's European tour...

babymetal BABYMETAL TO HEADLINE WEMBLEY ARENA NEXT APRIL
Can't wait till April? Two new live DVD releases have also been confirmed for October release...

cats in space CATS IN SPACE ANNOUNCE THE RELEASE OF DEBUT ALBUM 'TOO MANY GODS' FOR OCTOBER 2015
Welcome to a new brand of Power Pop Rock from a band with a stellar CV...

nightwish NIGHTWISH TO RELEASE 'ENDLESS FORMS MOST BEAUTIFUL' TOUR EDITION
The special edition is released on October 30th and comes with a DVD stuffed to the brim with bonus features...

iron maiden IRON MAIDEN ANNOUNCE MASSIVE 2016 WORLD TOUR
The new Ed Force One will take the band, crew and over 12 tons of equipment more than 55,000 miles (88,500km) around the planet...

glenn hughes BREAKING NEWS: GENE SIMMONS' HOME SEARCHED UNDER WARRANT IN CONNECTION WITH CHILD PORNOGRAPHY INVESTIGATION
Police have confirmed that neither the Kiss bass player or any members of his family are considered to be suspects in the investigation...

glenn hughes GLENN HUGHES UNVEILS OFFICIAL PHOTO OF NEW BAND
Glenn hits the UK for live shows in October. "There is no greater high than performing and to reach out to my fans..."

gentlemans pistols GENTLEMANS PISTOLS PREMIERE NEW TRACK 'THE SEARCHER' ONLINE
"The song is about becoming apathetic towards things you once enjoyed and searching for where you are going in life..."

vreid NEW ALBUM FROM NORWEGIAN METALLERS VREID IS RELEASED IN OCTOBER
"This is the definition of our lives and heritage...the fire burns stronger than ever..."

napalm death NAPALM DEATH JOIN UK LEG OF "DEATHCRUSHER" TOUR
The Deathcrusher tour contains the very best in Grindcore...

blitzkrieg EXCLUSIVE: BLITZKRIEG RELEASE 30TH ANNIVERSARY EDITION OF 'A TIME OF CHANGES'
The classic album has been completely re-recorded and contains two bonus tracks...

w.a.s.p. W.A.S.P. PREMIERE NEW SONG - 'LAST RUNAWAY'
"The song is an intensely personal account of what happened to me, not only then but over the years and the success that followed after..."

nervosa NERVOSA UNLEASH NEW VIDEO FOR 'INTO MOSHPIT'
The band are currently on tour in the UK...

metal allegiance METAL ALLEGIANCE POST STUDIO TRAILER FOR 'DESTINATION: NOWHERE'
The track features Matt Heafy on vocals and guitar. A special launch show has been arranged to celebrate the album release...

uriah heep URIAH HEEP STAGE CLASSIC REUNION WITH CORE MEMBERS OF THE CLASSIC 1970S LINE-UP
Ken Hensley and Lee Kerslake are welcomed to the Moscow Crocus in October for the exclusive event...

rage against the machine RAGE AGAINST THE MACHINE 'LIVE AT FINSBURY PARK' TO BE RELEASED
The free concert held after the success of the Christmas Number One campaign is now available in a quality package...

helloween HELLOWEEN ANNOUNCE LONDON FORUM SHOW FOR FEBRUARY 2016
"We feel pleased and honoured to yet again come to London UK..."

monkees THE MONKEES PLAY LONDON HAMMERSMITH EVENTIM APOLLO ON SEPTEMBER 4th
The set will include selections from the pyschedelic cult classic 'Head'...

rammstein RAMMSTEIN UNLEASH NEW 'RAMMSTEIN IN AMERIKA' DOCUMENTARY AND 'LIVE FROM MADISON SQUARE GARDEN' DVD
The incredible package is immaculately filmed and bursting with content...

amulet AMULET LAUNCH VIDEO FOR 'BLOODY NIGHT' & ANNOUNCE TOUR DATES
Be prepared for a Heavy Metal attack...

guitar of your dreams MAKE'N MUSIC ANNOUNCES $3,250 GUITAR GIVEAWAY
Calling all guitarists - there isn't a cooler giveaway throughout the entire industry...

dan patlansky JOE SATRIANI EXTENDS EUROPEAN TOUR WITH DAN PATLANSKY AS SPECIAL GUEST
This part of the tour now encompasses 10 countries, 25 shows and 33 days...

tad morose TAD MOROSE TO TOUR EUROPE IN SEPTEMBER WITH SILENT CALL
The Swedish double bill celebrates the release of Tad Morose's new album 'St Demonius'...

iron maiden IRON MAIDEN PREMIERE VIDEO FOR 'SPEED OF LIGHT'
The brand new track is taken from 'The Book Of Souls' double album due out on September 4th...

pentagram PENTAGRAM ANNOUNCE UK AND EUROPE SHOWS
"We all are itching to perform some of our songs off of our new album 'Curious Volume' for you..."

born again BORN AGAIN - HEAVY METAL SOUNDHOUSE DAYS REVISTED AT THE BLACK HEART CAMDEN
Relive the glory days on the 22nd August with the best music around...

wildfire FIRST BANDS ANNOUNCED FOR WILDFIRE FESTIVAL 2016
Scotland's stellar Rock and Metal festival starts the buzz for 2016 with six quality names...

hotei HOTEI TO RELEASE DEBUT INTERNATIONAL ALBUM 'STRANGERS' ON OCTOBER 16TH
With an impressive range of guests, the world renowned Japanese guitarist and songwriter unleashes an epic album...

rich robinson RICH ROBINSON ANNOUNCES ACOUSTIC TOUR FOR SEPTEMBER / OCTOBER 2015
The Black Crowes' guitarist presents a stripped down, storytelling evening...

sonic syndicate SONIC SYNDICATE ANNOUNCE NEW BASS PLAYER AFTER THE DEPARTURE OF KARIN AXELSSON
The band premiere the new line up with the profound video for 'Diabolical Work Of Art'...

motorhead MOTÖRHEAD ADD EXTRA LONDON SHOW TO 2016 EUROPEAN TOUR WITH SAXON AND GIRLSCHOOL
We suggest ear-plugs and fortitude, because Lemmy, Phil and Mikkey are more intent than ever on showing at great volume that they are Motörhead and they play rock n' roll...

venrez VENREZ PREMIERE NEW LYRIC VIDEO AHEAD OF MICHAEL SCHENKER EUROPEAN TOUR
'Children Of The Drones' is the title track of the new album...

majesty GHOST PREMIERE 'MAJESTY' FROM FORTHCOMING ALBUM 'MELIORA'
Papa Emeritus III and his nameless ghouls will return to North America and Europe with a tour this autumn...

imperial state electric IMPERIAL STATE ELECTRIC SUPPORT GRAVEYARD & RELEASE NEW ALBUM
The release of Imperial State Electric's 'Honk Machine' brings their live show to the UK for the first time...

chantel mcgregor CHANTEL McGREGOR ANNOUNCES HER NEW ALBUM 'LOSE CONTROL' AND UK TOUR DATES
After four years of touring and festival appearances, Chantel returns with a vengeance with ten new songs...

lynne jackaman SOUL-ROCK SONGSTRESS JACKAMAN PERFORMS NEW EP 'NO HALO' LIVE IN LONDON
The show at Camden's Barfly on September 24th is set to be memorable for all the right reasons...

steve hackett STEVE HACKETT RELEASES THIRD REHEARSAL VIDEO CLIP FOR 40TH ANNIVERSARY TOUR IN OCTOBER
Preparations appear to be going very well indeed...

steve n seagulls STEVE'N'SEAGULLS ANNOUNCE THE SEAGULL HAS LANDED UK TOUR & NEW VIDEO
Anyone for hillbillified Iron Maiden...?

gentlemans pistols GENTLEMANS PISTOLS ANNOUNCE TRACK LISTING AND UNVEIL THE ARTWORK FOR 'HUSTLER'S ROW'
"A turbulent voyage of the sweetest sufferings and the most inexpensive of thrills..."

queensryche QUEENSRŸCHE REVEAL ALBUM COVER ART AND TRACK-LISTING FOR 'CONDITION HÜMAN'
The hard rock giants continue to thrill with their latest offering...

udo U.D.O. SAYS FINAL FAREWELL TO ACCEPT'S CATALOGUE
In a surprise announcement Udo Dirkschneider has confirmed that he will no longer play songs from the Accept library after one final tour...

operation mindcrime OPERATION: MINDCRIME REVEAL 'RE-INVENTING THE FUTURE', THE FIRST SINGLE FROM NEW ALBUM
The release from Geoff Tate's current project marks the first of a trilogy of albums...


metal talk
© All written site content is copyright MetalTalk.net 2008-2015, unless otherwise stated, and is not to be used without prior permission.
Ads raid data recovery